> have to give credit where credit is do. You do this for a living?
Not specifically, but have been called in on data recovery jobs
many times.
>
> Right, but it doesnt hang on the blue stop sccreen, it just
> flashes it for a second then reboots. If that means anything.
In my experience, I've seen this when the system RAM was defective,
bad video or disk driver. Since you've swapped systems, the first
one isn't it. I imagine that you tried booting into Safe mode to
eliminate the last two. Then again, if the XP boot CD can't determine
the partition type, it's not even getting to the stage of loading
drivers.
>
>
> >This supprises me since the system is able to boot up to the
> >point of the stop message. Knoppix's ability to boot and
> >access IDE drives is excellent. Make SURE you are booting
> >Knoppix with the following bootcodes (cheatcodes):
> >nosound noapic noscsi nodma noswap nofstab
>
> Im using the new version of Knoppix with GUI. Ive taken it
> out of its host computer like you said and put it in another.
> It still does not show up on the KDE (desktop)
Try the following with both Knoppix and Insert (assuming you have
UBCD Full): At the bootprompt (cheatcode prompt)
boot: knoppix 2 nosound noapic noscsi nodma noswap nofstab
(For Insert in UBCD, hit F7, then F1, then..)
boot: insert 2 nosound noapic noscsi nodma noswap nofstab
At this point you should be at a command prompt. Type the
following:
fdisk -l
(That's l as in Larry)
This should be quite telling. You should see /dev/had
and /dev/hdb with both drives attached. Post the results.
The reason I'm suggesting both Knoppix and Insert is that
Knoppix is running a 2.6 Kernel and Insert is running 2.4.
When it comes to plain old IDE, both should detect drives
reliably but just to be sure...
> Yes, XP boot CD does detect the drive, but it says to the
> right in brackets [Unkown]
> The slave drive is detected to and it says: [FAT32]
OK, sounds like a corrupt partition.
> >If you can see the drive but are unable to access the partition then
> >the partition is corrupt.
>
> >If that's the case then you'll need a until to repair it.
>
> What do you mean?
I think I meant util; meaning a program designed to repair
corrupt partitions. I don't know of any open source or
free programs that do this; for $50 Disk Director has been
a good investment for me. Note that it uses Linux. If
Knoppix or Insert can't see the drive Disk Director may
not be able to either; but I've found it's device support
better than both Knoppix and Insert.
> OK, I guess if we make it this far we are getting somewhere.
> Disk Director, sounds like a worthy investment. Think it
> will work in my situation. After I repair the partition,
> which I have a feeling that it is damaged, then I will be
> able to see it knoppix. Should this remedy my problem?
> Well I can see it in XP boot, but not Knoppix. So what do
> you think about that?
Knoppix's inability to see the drive and XP's ability to see
it but not determine the partition type are two different issues.
But, I'm not 100% sure Knoppix can't see the drive. I'm not too
familiar with the GUI (KDE) tools in Knoppix so I stick to the
command line. The fdisk -l should tell us if it can see the
drive, and even if it can determine the partition type.
If the partition recovery works, then you should be able to
access it through all your utilities.
>
> OnTrack a team? they got a web site? Is this like last last resort.
> Whats a freezer trick?
OnTrack is a company that's been around for awhile. I used them
10+ years ago; it cost more than 10K. That's really only an option
when the cost of recovery is insignificant in comparison to data lost.
http://www.ontrack.com/ They also sell recovery software, which I
have not used. It appears only to recover files, not repair the
entire partition. Looks like they have a free trial that would identify
the files it could recover. Note there is a difference between a
failed drive and a corrupt partition. Only solution to a failed
drive is sending it in or freezing it.
The freezer trick is a last resort when the system can't even recognize
the drive. Search "HDD Freezer" on google. But, since that does not
seem to be your problem (XP can see it), I wouldn't try.
So, given your current status, I'd do the following:
- Test Knoppix and Insert at command line.
- If you can see the drive, report back cause then I'd
"dd" it before performing a partition recovery. Note
when I say "dd", I mean the unix utility dd, and not
Disk Director.
- If you made a backup with dd or, if you simply couldn't
see the drive through Knoppix or Insert, then I'd go
ahead with Disk Director. Download and install on a
working machine, create a boot disk, then insert in the
system with the failed drive. The recovery could take
4-8hrs. depending upon how big the partition is.
- If recovery works, copy files from it immediately.